These light and sweet whipped shortbread cookies, with a cherry on top, are so quick and easy to make. Christmas cookie perfection!
It’s almost Christmas time – which means it’s time to make some whipped shortbread cookies!
I absolutely love Christmas baking. The only problem is that as the years pass, I am starting to have too many favourites! We have to pick and choose every year now.
Especially since I do love to bake, and there’s all my childhood favourites, all my husband’s childhood favourites, and I have this need to try new things every year too. That makes for far too many cookies.
So not everything gets made, or we’d have Christmas baking in the freezer all year long.
These whipped shortbread cookies get made every single year though. Without fail. They’re my absolute favourite Christmas cookie – and I don’t even like candied cherries that much, so if they’re not your thing either, don’t let them stop you from making these!
Oddly enough, even though this is my mom’s recipe, it’s virtually identical to the one my mother-in-law makes. So it’s on both mine and my husband’s list.
Basically, they’re the perfect Christmas cookie.
Whipped shortbread were the only cookie that my whole family would always make together every year when I was growing up.
I think we’d usually make a double or triple batch because they were everyone’s favourite!
We’d all have jobs. Dad would mix the dough and roll it into little balls, I’d press each one down with a fork, and my sister and brother would stick the cherries on top. I figured I had the best job because I never liked touching the sticky cherries. My son agrees with me on that and won’t help with that part.
Evidently my mom got stuck with cleanup? I don’t remember. I do remember that making whipped shortbread equated to Christmas being just around the corner.
If you’ve never tried whipped shortbread, add this one to your “new Christmas cookies to try” list. Maybe you’ll find a new family favourite too!
Why is it called shortbread?
It’s called shortbread because of the large amount of butter in the cookies. The term short means crumbly, like pastry should be.
So shortbread cookies are buttery cookies that are a bit crumbly.
Don’t expect a chewy cookie – shortbread cookies are crisp, lightly sweet, and a bit crumbly.
What does shortbread taste like?
There is a lot of butter in shortbread, but not as much sugar as you might expect, like sugar cookies.
Shortbread has a buttery, lightly sweet taste. They are not overly sweet.
If you like your cookies really sweet, you might prefer sugar cookies to shortbread.
Can you freeze shortbread cookies?
Yes, I freeze my whipped shortbread cookies all the time.
Place the cooled cookies in an airtight container with wax paper in between the layers of cookies to prevent them sticking together and freeze for up to 3 months.
They defrost very quickly at room temperature, and are very good even when they’re still cold.
How to make Whipped Shortbread Cookies:
- You can use a stand mixer, food processor or electric hand mixer to make these cookies – I’ve used all three with good results.
- Make sure you whip the dough well. It will be crumbly at first and then will come together into a ball – this takes 2-3 minutes of whipping in a stand mixer or food processor, and 4-5 minutes with an electric hand mixer. It takes longer than most cookie doughs to mix but the cookies will be difficult to roll into balls if you don’t whip the dough long enough.
- If candied cherries don’t appeal to you, you can make them without or put something else (chocolate, nuts, sprinkles, whatever you like) on top, but keep in mind that the cookies themselves aren’t super sweet.
- If you have a cookie press, these cookies can also be shaped with one of those instead of rolling the dough into balls and pressing it down with a fork.
-
Here are some more fantastic Christmas cookie recipes for you:
These light and sweet whipped shortbread cookies, topped with a cherry, are quick and easy to make. They make the perfect Christmas cookies! Be sure to measure the flour correctly for these cookies. I use the dip and sweep method to measure my flour (fluff up the flour in the bin first, then scoop with your measuring cup and level it off with a knife or flat edge). I also measure my powdered sugar and cornstarch this way. I've included the weights as well, so you can use a kitchen scale instead if you have one. When whipping the dough, be sure to keep whipping until the dough has come together into a ball and is light and fluffy. It will be crumbly at first but will be smooth after whipping it for 2-3 minutes in a stand mixer or food processor, or 4-5 minutes with an electric mixer. If candied cherries aren't your thing, chunks of chocolate are good, or nothing at all - the cookies are great on their own too! Source: My mom has been making this recipe for as long as I can remember! This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I may receive a small commission from qualifying purchases.Whipped Shortbread
Ingredients
Instructions
Notes
Recommended Products
Nutrition Information:
Yield:
30
Serving Size:
1 cookie
Amount Per Serving:
Calories: 93Total Fat: 6.2gSaturated Fat: 3.9gCholesterol: 16mgSodium: 44mgCarbohydrates: 8.9gFiber: 0.2gSugar: 2.8gProtein: 0.7g
These were quick easy and yummy!! I did have to add a few tablespoons of milk to get it to form a dough, otherwise it was just staying powdery.
Just wondering if these would need any salt since the recipe calls for unsalted butter?
I never add any. That being said, I have made them with salted butter instead and they are just as good. So you can definitely use salted butter instead if you like – I don’t actually find it matters too much for these cookies.
The butter is separating the cookies look horrible not sure why followed the recipe
Hi Ann – I’m sorry, I’ve never had that happen. The only thing I can think of is that maybe your butter was too soft when you started so it warmed up a lot when whipping? It should be soft enough that it will indent when you press a spoon into the side, but the spoon shouldn’t slide right through it. Hopefully that helps!
I used a recipe from Best of Bridge that called for mixing ingredients for 10 minutes (said more mixing the better) so I used my food processor. The butter melted and mixture separated. Can I still use when butter hardens or should I throw out.
I’ve never had that happen Amy, that’s too bad! I would certainly still try using it once the butter hardens again – worth a try. I would put the dough into the fridge and let it firm up again (not cold and rock hard, just firm enough that it’s solid and about room temp again) and then try mixing it to bring it together again (maybe with cookie paddles in a stand mixer instead if you have one?), and bake them. I’ve never had that happen (and I’ve made these with my food processor many times – but I mix for 2-3 minutes in the food processor) so I’m not positive it will work, but it’s worth a try. Good luck!
For powdered sugar can I use icing sugar As we don’t get powdered sugar here in Canada… have seen super fine grain sugar…
Thx
Powdered sugar and icing sugar are the same thing. I tend to use either word – I’m in Canada and have always called it icing sugar, but always got a lot of questions asking what it was when I said that so have started saying powdered sugar more often now. I need to just start putting both words I think!
Powered sugar is same as icing sugar. For some odd reason Americans tend to refer to it as powdered.
I’ve made these for years, but mine are called “Pastel Melt-Aways”. You can tint the dough too, also roll two colors in a log and cut or roll in colored dots. I don’t use the candied jellies. Great recipe.
Made this and it was super easy. Worked out great and was soooo light and tasty. Delicious!
Do you measure the flour and then sift it, or do you sift the flour and then measure it,
I measure the flour first, then sift it before mixing it in.
Wonderful shortbread cookies! Thank you for sharing!
I just made these and they are AMAZING! I skipped the cherry and dipped half the cookie in melted dark chocolate and added sprinkles for the kiddos. Thanks so much for sharing This! Will be making these forever now I’m sure! 🙂
Love the dipping in chocolate idea – I definitely need to do that next time! I’m not a big fan of the cherry myself and always make some plain, but the kids love the cherries. So glad you loved them!
What is the correct length of baking time? The video says 10 minutes, written instructions say 12-14.
Sorry Barbara – the written recipe is correct – typo in the video. I will have to re-edit that to make it right! Thanks for letting me know!
Do these work with margarine or vegan butter? I’d love to make them for potlucks so people with different dietary needs can still have a delicious treat!
We have made them before with margarine (the hard brick kind, not the soft kind in the tub) and they work well, the flavour is just a bit different. I haven’t ever tried them with vegan butter though.
Can you make the dough and freeze to bake at at later time?
I’ve never actually tried that as the dough mixes up very quickly. I have frozen the baked cookies (every year in fact) and they defrost very quickly when we want to have them. We will pull out a plateful and they will be defrosted within 10-15 minutes of taking them from the freezer so that’s always been the way I’ve frozen them. I think if you wanted to freeze the dough to bake later it would probably work just fine after defrosting, but I haven’t actually tried it so I can’t say for sure!
Made these today, don’t know if I did anything wrong. I found them very dry and not sweet at all.
Shortbread isn’t overly sweet, and it does have a dry, crisp texture. It’s not supposed to be a moist, chewy cookie – they’re meant to be lightly sweet, crisp, melt in your mouth cookies. So if that’s what you ended up with then you likely did everything right! You might like these sugar cookies better if you’re looking for a sweeter cookie that’s chewy instead of crisp.
I made them tonight and they definitely could have used a bit more sugar! They were light and crisp and had perfect texture! I’m just used to having them a bit more sweeter
Love this recipe! Super easy, simple to double or triple. And I love the delicate, crumbly crispness. Much better than store bought. My little girl said they weren’t sweet enough, but I explained that was what shoetbread was. I can’t wait to pair this with a coffee or tea.
I made these yesterday & they are delicious & so easy. I have never had such a light & tender shortbread. They look like they take a long time, but are very quick. They are such a beautiful Christmas cookie with the cherries on top, but I think I will be making them year round because I can’t stop eating them. Thank you for sharing your recipe.
These turned out absolutely perfect! Thank you for the recipe!
So glad you liked them!
Made these today, they were so yummy!
Thanks for sharing the recipe!
I made these today and not sure what went wrong. The cookies flattened out during baking and then got really brown around the edges…
Hi Chrissy, I’m sorry I’ve never had that happen with these! Two things it might be is oven temperature. If your oven runs hotter then the temperature you set that can cause cookies to spread too much. Or if you aren’t weighing your flour you might get less per cup then I do and have too little flour in the cookie dough. That can cause your cookies to spread too much as well. Hope that helps!
Thanks for your reply!! I think I didn’t have enough flour in them like you mentioned. They were still a big hit at the party tho!! Delicious 🙂
I’m glad they still tasted good! 🙂
Can these be rolled out and cut with a cookie cutter?
I’ve never tried that, so I don’t know. I think if you wanted to try you would want to chill the dough though, they tend to spread a bit in the oven so the shapes probably wouldn’t hold unless the dough was chilled. Let me know if you try it, and how it works! I do have this sugar cookie recipe if you want one for rolling and using a cookie cutter though: https://bake-eat-repeat.com/sugar-cookies-recipe/
Thanks so much for posting this!! First time making shortbread and it worked perfectly:)
So glad it worked out well for you! 🙂
Hi Stacey,
I am sabiha,nice cookies.can u also display a chart showing how much calories, etc. Plz. Cause I just love all types of cookies so I have gained weight to 80.9. Now I am conscious,want to reduce.
Thanks
Reply
Hi Sabiha – I’m glad you like the cookies! I don’t actually display nutritional information on my recipes as that info can really vary based on the different brands of some products. If you would like to find out the nutritional info for any recipe on my site, you can easily copy and paste the ingredients into an online nutritional calculator to find out.
Please send me the whipped shortbread recipe for bake eat and repeat?
Hi Patsy – the recipe is at the end of this post, after the video and before the comment section.
Would like to have this recipe,looks so good
The recipe is at the bottom of this post, immediately after the video and before the comment section.
These cookies look so good. Please send to my email @ 01gmichie@gmail. Com
Thanks Gail – the recipe is right on the post, below the video and above the comments. If you’re on mobile, there is a button that you have to click that says “read more” right before the comments that will bring up the rest of the post. In the recipe card box there is a “print” button so you can print it out if you want. Let me know if you have any trouble!
I’ve been making these at Christmas for years and as you say they are foolproof. So tickled to see that you are now doing videos. Your recipes are wonderful and your photography is fabulous. Thanks so much. Love your blog.
Cheers
Shelley
Thanks so much Shelley – that’s so nice of you! 🙂
What a great video, Stacey! … and this recipe is not only easy, but melt in your mouth delicious, just as you said they would be.
Thank you!
These cookies look so tasty! We always did shortbread cookies growing up but I haven’t had them in years. I think I’ll add them to my baking list this year!
Hi can you please give me the measurements in ounces. That would be great because I do not have cup measure. Thank you!
I get 5 ounces of flour per cup when I weigh it. I haven’t weighed the other ingredients for this recipe yet, but am planning to update it with all the weights this year when I make them! You could probably find the conversions online for most of the other ingredients though.
Can u please share ur recipes for short bread cookies
The recipe is right below the video, and above the comments on the post.
I just made these and they seemed to be perfect – Until I started baking them..the whole cookie sheet is one big cookie! it just melted together. I measured as descried and used standmixer..
Oh no! I’m not sure what could have happened, I’ve never had that happen with these. I use a shiny aluminum baking pan and don’t grease it, not sure if you did anything different there that could affect things. I’ve also read that an oven that runs even 25 degrees hotter then it’s supposed to can cause that. Other then that I’m not sure what it could be! Sorry they didn’t work out for you!
My oven runs hotter so knowing that I baked at the time you suggested 12-14 but at 425 worked great:)
I thought these were so easy to make and just melt in your mouth
Hi Stacey. I have made these cookies twice in the past week and they were delicious! I mixed for several minutes with a wooden spoon. The dough went from crumbly to smooth in a few minutes. These have become a family favourite. Merry Christmas, Ei
I’m so glad you liked them! Thank you so much for letting me know! Merry Christmas to you too!
How long should you whip the butter before adding the other ingredients? How long do you whip the dough? Mine didn’t turn out quite right and I measured like you said.
I whip the butter for 1-2 minutes in a stand mixer before adding the other ingredients – basically until it’s fluffy and there aren’t any more lumps in it. Then I add the rest of the ingredients and whip again, for probably 2-3 minutes. It will be very crumbly at first and then come together into a dough at which point I mix for another 30 seconds or so until it’s smooth. It will be a smooth, tacky cookie dough. What went wrong with yours?
I had mixed reviews. I think it’s more of a persons preference. My husband didn’t like that they were kid of paste like in his mouth, for lack of a better words. My coworkers loved them.
I think most things are like that – everyone isn’t going to like everything! I’m glad your coworkers enjoyed them! 🙂
Taste was great and melt in mouth but they don’t hold up they just fall apart
I’m sorry they didn’t work out for you Roxanne. All I can think is maybe you measure flour differently then I do? I’ve been making these cookies for years and have never found them crumbly. I use the dip and sweep method for measuring flour which will give about 5 ounces of flour per cup, and I sift after measuring, not before. I also whip the dough for several minutes before it comes together into a smooth dough, it is crumbly at first. Hopefully that helps!
worst cookies ever, they taste like sand and fall apart like it!!!! Don’t know what went wrong!
Hi Michelle – I’m so sorry they didn’t turn out for you – I’m not sure what went wrong. My family has been making this recipe as long as I can remember and they are always wonderful. I use the scoop and sweep method to measure the flour/corn starch in this recipe so maybe if you use a different method you ended up with a different amount of flour in your dough? That’s all I can think that could cause the difference.
I have been searching online for a shortbread cookie recipe and my gosh there are plenty to choose from! Your recipe seemed to be one that I could make so I printed it off, got all the ingredients and made it tonight. It’s the first time ever I made shortbread cookies so I was a little scared I would fail. I am so happy to say these cookies turned out perfectly!!! In fact they were sooooo good I made a second batch while the first one was still cooling on the counter! It was so important to me to find a recipe like this one.This recipe makes shortbread cookies that are very light,fluffy and melt in your mouth as soon as you eat them! My friend who always made them for our family every year as a X-Mas gift passed away earlier this year so I really wanted to make shortbread cookies like hers so in a way her spirit is still with us as we enjoy shortbread cookies. I know she is with us in spirit but it just seemed to feel better with cookies around like the ones she made and this recipe is so close to hers , I think she would be very proud of me for how these turned out! I like to believe her hands were helping mine as I was making these delicious shortbread cookies! thank-you so much for sharing this recipe. I will be making these every year! Merry Christmas! 🙂
So glad you liked the cookies Michelle! Merry Christmas!
There is no baking instructions? Pls add so i can
Make them thank you
Hi Tammy, the instructions are right on the recipe card – below the video and right before the comments.
Do you sift the powdered sugar/ flour before measuring it or after measuring it?
I sift after measuring. I use the scoop and sweep method for measuring my flour (and powdered sugar), fluffing up the flour a bit before scooping it so that it’s not packed down at all, and then sweeping the excess flour off the top of the measuring cup with a knife. I find I get the most accurate measurement this way. I then sift it into the bowl I’m using to make the cookies.
Great photos of the most delicious shortbread cookies EVER! When I asked Dad what his favourite Christmas cookie he wanted me to bake ‘for sure’ this year, it was, as you mentioned, our family favourite, Whipped Shortbread. It just wouldn’t be Christmas without them! Yours look PERFECT! I hope mine look as yummy, so that my grand-kids enjoy mine as much as yours! (even if it IS the same recipe)
One thing you’ve shown me that is different, though, is to roll the dough into balls and flatten them slightly with the fork. I’ve always done them as ‘drop’ cookies, and they end up in various sizes …. thanks, Stacey!
I have never made whipped short breads but I think I’ll try. Can these be put through a cookie press?
I really like the whipped short bread. It’s much lighter and more delicate than the regular shortbread. I know my husband and father-in-law don’t even like regular shortbread, but they love these, so it is different. I have never used a cookie press for them myself, but my aunt always uses a cookie press for this recipe, and I think my sister has too, so you definitely can! Hope you enjoy them!
wow! I’m so glad you are doing this. Whipped shortbread is my favorite too. I do almost no baking at my house ( because we would eat it and we don’t need any more treats) but, it’s not Christmas without it. However, my mom always did them like a drop cookie rather than a ball but it still had that cherry thing on top. I can remember as a child, hiding those discussing things all over the house. Now I have fun experimenting with other thing to put on top. I’ve tried pecans, m&m’s, smarties, And chocolate. Pretty much anything I have that’s sweet. Keep blogging girl!
Thanks Jessica! Glad you like it! I will admit, I’m not a huge fan of the cherries myself, but most people love them, and I will say that they look pretty! I may have to switch it up for chocolate one year though, that would be fantastic.
These cookies are absolutely gorgeous! So perfect for the holidays.
These are so pretty and easy to make too! I wanted to let you know that I am linking to this post if you don’t mind. You’re welcome to share your photos at my site if you’d like.
Thanks Alyssa! I don’t mind at all if you link to this post. Thanks for sharing!
So sweet and cute looking cookies! Perfect treat for holidays! Pinning!
these look wonderful! I love how easy they are and the Christmas themed colors 😉 super cute!
These look delicious!! Love the cherries on top – makes them so fun and festive.
Time does speed up once you have kids, Stacey! It’s very disconcerting.
These are gorgeous! I can see why they’re your fave!
Funny: We still have a ton of Halloween candy left as well but I still love to bake Christmas cookies anyway! I love these yummy shortbread cookies. I could probably inhale the whole batch!! 🙂
These are my all time favorite cookies Stacey! And we also like to make them together with my family! Yours are zoo cute! Pinning and making them soon!
I definitely cannot believe it’s well into December … I feel like I’ve gotten nothing done yet! But I guess I feel like that just about every year! 🙂
Cookies like this are my favorite … the ones that are family recipes we make over and over. These look wonderful!!
so festive and so cute! Pinned!
These look amazing and oh so pretty… like perfect shortbread! Wishing I had one to try right now!
This looks amazing and I love the idea of whipped shortbread… wow!
These look FABULOUS!! I’ve never seen shortbread with the fork marks. I love it!
Christmas baking is my favorite! Can’t believe how fast Christmas is creeping up on us this year too! I have so many things I still want to make – like these cookies! They look so pretty and festive!
they look great! Can’t wait to get home and try those
I’ve never heard of whipped shortbread! These look so fluffy and delicious. Happy baking!
I LOVE Christmas baking! These are so festive and I love how simple the recipe is! Pinned 🙂
You still have Halloween candy? That’s so funny! It’s also such a coincidence that your own family’s recipe is so similar to your in-laws! That sure worked out well! These cookies are super pretty and they look so buttery and delicate. I’ve never tried whipped shortbread (that concept is brand new to me actually), and I must try these soon! I know what you mean though… so many recipes to try! I hate narrowing down! Haha. 🙂
I know! It’s hard not to make everything! I really wish there was a way to make like a quarter batch of everything, but the one egg in most recipes always messes me up! So hard to use half an egg! 🙂 If you’ve never tried whipped shortbread, you need to, I love it. It’s so much better than the regular shortbread which I find kind of dry and hard. Maybe I just haven’t had a good one though!
I can’t believe that it’s December 8th either! Christmas will be here before we know it! These shortbread cookies are so adorable, Stacey! I love the candied cherries in the middle. These are some of my favorite Christmas cookies, love them!
I’ve made this recipe too from my Mom’s collection. I also make it by replacing the sugar with 4 year old cheddar cheese and a 1/4 to 1/2 teaspoon of cayenne powder depending on your appetite for a bite! Try it – their great with a glass of wine or a cocktail.
I have never tried a savoury version of shortbread but it sounds like a fantastic idea! I’ll have to try that this year – thanks Bob!
does-it-got-to be unsalted-butter??????
Hi Stacy,
I made your whipped shortbread cookies they were delicious, Ive made whipped shortbread for years but used double the cornstarch and my recipe never called for vanilla and i think that’s the secret to the taste of your cookies ,cant wait to try some more of your recipes .
thanks
So glad you liked them Jean! Thanks so much for commenting and letting me know! I hope you find more recipes you love here! 🙂