Jalapeño Pineapple Jelly

I am going to start this by saying outright that I’ve never been particularly fond of jalapeño jelly.  Every year on Christmas Eve, my extended family gets together and we do a potluck style meal involving truckloads of appetizers.  Jalapeño jelly pretty much always makes an appearance.  Generally with crackers or maybe those little phyllo cups with cream cheese.  I never have any.  Ever.  Just not my thing.

But this?  Could. not. stop. eating it.  So addictive.  I don’t know if it was the addition of pineapple, or just the fact that it was homemade, but this jalapeño pineapple jelly is so good.  I’ve had it on crackers with cream cheese, and even slathered it on a turkey sandwich with dill pickles.  I kind of thought that was weird as I did it, but it was awesome.

I’m really glad the recipe made 6 jars, cause now we won’t be running out any time soon!  Especially since the kids refuse to try anything involving spice of any kind!
Jalapeño Pineapple Jelly - Bake.Eat.Repeat.

But this jelly isn’t even all that spicy.  It has a hint of spiciness to it, but the sweetness of the jelly kind of offsets it, just leaving that bit of bite.  So addictive.  And you can make it spicier or milder depending on how many jalapeños you choose to seed.  I seeded half of them and left the seeds in the other half, and that was perfect for us.

And there’s the fun of canning!  I love canning, something so lovely about the sound of all those jars popping away as they seal.  That makes me sound like quite the nerd, but that’s okay.  I love it, I’m not afraid to admit it.  And we get lots of amazing jalapeño pineapple jelly as a result!

So, any other cooking nerds out there that love canning?  Or am I all alone on that one?!

Jalapeño Pineapple Jelly - Bake.Eat.Repeat.

Yield: 6 - 250mL jars of jelly (half-pint jars)

Jalapeño Pineapple Jelly

Jalapeño Pineapple Jelly

*Note:* This recipe needs liquid fruit pectin, not original fruit pectin. I tried it with the original pectin the first time and it doesn’t gel completely with that pectin. With the liquid pectin it gels perfectly. Also, I seeded 4 of the 8 jalapenos, and that was the perfect amount of spiciness for us. If you want it spicier, leave seeds in more of them, less if you want it a bit milder. With 4 seeded of the 8 it had a bit of bite to it, but not too much.


  • 1 red bell pepper
  • 8 jalapenos
  • 1/2 medium pineapple (about 1 1/2 cup chopped)
  • 1 1/2 cups white vinegar
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 5 cups granulated sugar
  • 1 85mL pouch liquid fruit pectin (3 oz pouch)


  1. In a food processor fitted with the shredding blade, or with a sharp knife, finely chop the red bell pepper, jalapenos (seeding as many as you like, I seeded 4), and the pineapple. In a large pot, combine the peppers and the pineapple with the vinegar, salt and sugar. Bring the mixture to a boil over medium heat and allow to boil for 10 minutes, stirring constantly.
  2. Add the liquid pectin and boil for 1 more minute. Remove the pot from the heat and pour into clean, hot canning jars, leaving 1/4 inch of headspace. Wipe the tops with a damp cloth to remove any stickiness and place a new lid and ring on the jar, making sure not to tighten the ring more than fingertip tight.
  3. Place the jars in a boiling water canner and process for 10 minutes, adding additional time depending on your altitude (there’s info for the amount of time to add on the pectin box, I needed to add 5 minutes). After processing, allow the jars to sit undisturbed for 24 hours for the jelly to completely set. Any jars that don’t seal, store in the refrigerator, it should last for up to a month. The sealed jars will be fine for 1-2 years on the shelf.


Source: Adapted from Mel’s Kitchen Cafe.


  1. Stacy says:

    Hi Stacey. I made this recipe today and cannot wait to try it. I LOVE Pepper Jelly! I have two quick questions for you.
    The first one is — I barely had enough jelly to fill 5 half-pint containers. I’m guessing that it’s because of the volume of fruit that I used? I’m guessing that my peppers were smaller than yours and maybe my pineapple was chunked bigger so there wasn’t really as much pineapple? Any other ideas?
    And my second question, I’m new to canning. I’m fortunate enough to be picking my first crop of White Pineapples. They are ‘lower in acid’ than normal Gold pineapples. I would like to can enough of this to keep on the shelf. Do I need to adjust the acid in the recipe or is there enough acid in the vinegar to do the job, regardless of the acid in the fruit?
    Thank you for your advice AND your recipe!

    1. Stacey says:

      I haven’t made this recipe in ages, hoping to make it again this year and add some volume measurements for the peppers. I’m guessing that would be the difference in how many jars you got. As far as using a different type of pineapple – if the acidity is lower I’m not sure if it would be okay. The original recipe that I adapted this from does use another red pepper and two more jalapeños, so I would think that if your white pineapple has the same acidity or higher (lower pH if you find a chart) as peppers do then you’d be fine. Golden pineapple has a lower pH then peppers so I know that that’s okay to replace the peppers with as it increases the acidity of the overall recipe. Whether white pineapple is fine for this recipe I can’t tell you – but you could find out the acidity of it and if it’s pH is lower then 4.6 it should be fine. Hope that helps!

    1. Stacey says:

      I haven’t ever tried it with canned pineapple but I think that it would be okay if you drain it first and still use 1 1/2 cups of pineapple. Not having tried it I couldn’t say for sure that it would turn out the same though!

  2. Donna says:

    Hello Stacy. How would you say the heat registers in this jelly compared to picante sauce, being mild, medium, or hot? We like ours medium to hot. I made strawberry jalapeno last year and it has been a huge hit. I can’t wait to try the pineapple jalapeno.

    1. stacey says:

      I think I would say medium? It is spicy but not overly so (with four of the jalapeños seeded and four not) and the sweet part kind of offsets that. If you want it milder maybe only leave seeds in two of the jalapeños, or six if you want it spicier. I have found that jalapeños vary a bit in how spicy they are though which is why I go with half of them for this recipe so the heat isn’t overpowering! Also please send me that recipe for strawberry jalapeño jelly – that sounds amazing and I really want to make it now!! 🙂

  3. vic says:

    so last weekend I made my first jelly and I wanted to do a jalapeno something so I ended up doing this one. to tell ya the truth I was scared of ruining it and wasting money but I ended up making myself rather proud of my self lol… so all in all it was a good experience, it came together well, my jars ceiled right and not to mention the amazing flavor of this recipe, thank you for that… my only down fall, which doesn’t bug me a whole lot, but the jelly didn’t set and its still runny. I did everything word by word and I just don’t know where I messed up…any pointers cause I want to do another batch this weekend…

    1. stacey says:

      Oh that’s too bad – it’s so disappointing when jam/jelly doesn’t set properly! I haven’t made this one in a while, but I have typically found when jam doesn’t gel properly for me, it’s often because the pectin was old/expired so it didn’t work well, there was more liquid in the batch then there should have been for the amount of pectin, or it wasn’t boiled long enough. Usually I try boiling it longer to try and get it to gel before anything else. Also you should leave the lid off the pot when you’re boiling – not sure if you did that or not? You can test whether it will set before you pour it into the jars and process them so you’re not disappointed – just leave a metal spoon in a glass of ice water and when you have finished boiling the jelly, just scoop out a little of the boiling liquid on the cool spoon and move it out of the steam – it should gel visibly and sheet off the spoon when you tip it as it cools. If it isn’t gelling on the spoon, keep boiling, testing every minute until it does. If it isn’t gelling after a few tests, you might need to add more pectin (maybe your pectin is old or there’s just too much liquid for some reason). Also it needs to be at a full rolling boil that you can’t stir down. Hope that helps!

  4. Mom says:

    I was lucky enough to be given a jar of this and tested it out yesterday, it was delicious!!! I may have to make a batch when I’m down south this winter. Thanks again for the jar of jelly

  5. mira says:

    I’ve always wanted to make some sort of jalapeño jelly, but never found the right recipe. Planning to try this! I love the addition of pineapple as well! Great to spread on crackers or toast. Pinned!

  6. I love this, Stacey! I’ve never had jalapeno jelly and wasn’t sure it’d be something I’d like, but THIS I would like! These flavors together sound awesome. I love canning and making jams and stuff too – I make peach and strawberry jams every summer with my Mom and Gma! 🙂 The pop is pretty gratifying, huh? TGIF! Have a good weekend!

  7. The flavors sound amazing in this jelly! I’ve never made my own before but I love the sound of jalapeños and pineapple together. I would totally find any excuse to slather this on everything or just eat it by the spoonful 🙂

    1. stacey says:

      I actually love spicy things, just never been a fan of spicy jelly, it just didn’t seem right to me! But this is entirely different than the stuff you buy at the store, so much better. Thanks so much for your kind words Gayle, and for the pin!

    1. stacey says:

      Ooh, pineapple and jalapeño in tacos?! That sounds awesome, I’ve never thought of doing that. Definitely going to have to try that sometime! Thanks Dannii!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *